The attentive programmer
Published July 11, 2024
This video features Daniele Procida at DjangoCon Europe 2026 in Athens, Greece.
KEYNOTE: Body of knowledge by Daniele Procida
What really makes Django's documentation so good? What's significant about the idea of a handbook? And why does software need to pay attention to the body?
More information: https://2026.djangocon.eu/speakers/FDRCZ3/
Follow DjangoCon Europe on social media:
*X - https://x.com/DjangoConEurope/
*LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/company/djangocon-europe/
*Mastodon - https://fosstodon.org/@djangoconeurope
#django #djangocon #djangoconeurope #djangoconeurope2026
Automatically transcribed, so expect mistakes in names and technical terms.
Speaker 1: Alright, so I hope that uh you had nice time uh last evening. I see you here, so this means that uh you had some sleep as well, hopefully at least. Um and uh yeah so a few things about today. Today during lunch towards the end of it we will also put an announcement in Zulip and uh we will update the schedule We will have a photograph for all the conference so make sure that you are in the networking area so that we can grab a nice shot with everybody from Athens because we need to uh Uh what else? We have a closing session. We end around uh 5 30 today and I'm sure I'm forgetting something but I will remember it and you know when I'm back on stage I will uh I will share it as well. So
Speaker 1: in the important stuff, the third keynote for the conference is uh Daniele Prosida. Um some of you might know him already. Actually personally I met him uh how many years? It was uh tw uh twenty 13 or 12? 14 14. So 12 years ago um he organized Django Django dei Cardiff, the first Django conference I attended with Paris uh my my colleague who's also in the organizing team so thanks a lot for that it was uh really amazing and uh he's a director of engineering at canonical And uh he's going to have a combination of philosophy and engineering talk. It's very interesting from uh the description. So Uh body of knowledge is the title, but I'm sure we will learn more uh from him.
Speaker 1: So thanks a lot for coming and for everything. Have a nice conference.
Speaker 2: Thank you very much. Good morning, everyone. I'll do a little introduction. So as oh, do I need my slides? Let's wait for my slides. Oh there we go. Um I'm Daniele, I I work at uh Canonical. That's what I look like on television. Um and um I've been involved in Python and Django and its communities for mm fifteen years or so. Um as uh Anthony said that uh he's closing the circle by inviting me to a conference that he and Paris are organizing. Um Thank you to Paris
Speaker 2: and Antonis and all the crew and volunteers who have put this on for us once again. A five-day Django festival that we all come together for. So thank you. I'm really grateful that people find the time and energy to do these things. I won't say more about myself, but um I'm gonna be here for the sprints as well. Um I did a workshop yesterday on how to be a successful job candidate. There's a link to a document there. You can find all the interesting details and things if you want them. Come and talk to me about well anything you like, but um jobs, uh Python and open source software in Africa, documentation, one of my
Speaker 2: specialities working at Canonical I'm hiring um lots of people in lots of different roles you might be interested in. It's really special to be here in Athens because in my intellectual map of the world, this is where everything starts. This is a foundational city. And it's the place where thinking as a business got its first outing You know, the the thinking industry started here. And right now I can pick up a thread in the intellectual fabric of our world and follow it back to its origin, and this is usually where it seems to end up This is special
Speaker 2: uh territory and if I find myself looking for a concept I generally start digging around here and I rarely come away empty-handed. There's always something some idea that I can draw upon. And I help myself to Greek ideas very generously, so you're likely familiar with this. It's just one example where it has worked very well for me. And when I want a name for something, this is uh where I come looking. And in a personal way too, this this place is where a lot of things got going for me. Because About two and a half thousand years ago, Socrates , the philosopher, was put on trial and executed here in Athens. Actually, not very far at all from where we are right now.
Speaker 2: And when I got to university, not two and a half thousand years ago, but quite a few years ago, um That was the first text I had to study, four of Plato's dialogues around the events of the death of Socrates, and it made quite an impression on me. Um so Socrates as Uh I'm sure you may know some of this story. He was accused of heresy and corrupting the youth of Athens. And Uh these are actually rather malicious charges and they were brought by politically hostile people because here uh Socrates um Uh um he didn't seem to have a job, but he went around irrit irritating people by exposing their personal hypocrisy and asking difficult questions and generally puncturing their balloons.
Speaker 2: He was carrying a very Sharp kind of dialectical pin with him. So he made himself a nuisance amongst powerful people. And here he is at his trial defending himself in a speech to the jury. And unfortunately, he was found guilty by a majority of 280 votes to 221. And then after that his accusers asked for the death penalty And Socrates got to make a plea in response. And that speech must have really got up the noses of the jury because this time 360 of the 501 jurors voted for the death penalty. So, you know Eighty of them voted not guilty, but when it came to the sentence, they decided he ought to be put to death anyway.
Speaker 2: And h how do you manage that? That thanks to your speech on the question of the sentence, um 80 jurors who thought you were not guilty. Now think you should be executed, it it's almost impossible to achieve such a thing unless you're actually trying to annoy people on purpose. So In his final address, Socrates told the assembled jury that he would be leaving condemned to death, but that they would be remembered as Having um uh they be they'd leave being convicted of wickedness and depravity by truth herself. For convicting uh for for executing an innocent man, and that that would be much worse. And and he was right. So two and a half thousand years later, we still remember Athens as the city that executed Socrates
Speaker 2: who asked inconvenient questions on behalf of truth. I think there are some people from Athens here, aren't there? Anyone? Anyone from Athens? Who feel a bit ashamed? So in fact actually all of Athens was nearly all of Athens was really embarrassed by this whole uh affair. It looked really bad. What they really wanted was for Socrates just to shut up and go away There weren't actually that many people who who wanted him dead. And the authorities engineered the execution plans in such a way that Socrates would give them plenty of time. and every opportunity to solve their problem by escaping into exile, which is what all his friends begged him to do. But Socrates refused, arguing that it would be um an offence against the laws of Athens
Speaker 2: uh to do so. Um so he submitted to his punishment with equanimity, and when the time came and everybody around him was racked with despair and grief He calmly took the hemlock, the poison that he was given to drink, and uh he took it without fear or anger. This is my favorite painting of the death of Socrates. Uh I like this one because Socrates Up until the last minute he's still busy teaching, even while he's reaching for the cup of uh hemlock And of course this is a that was a moment that also started everything in another sense because Plato was absolutely outraged by the injustice. He was devastated by the death of his friend and teacher at the hands of the state, and it filled him with a
Speaker 2: passion to honor and preserve the memory of Socrates, and it was a passion so powerful that it came to define our world. There is nothing in Western thought that hasn't been touched by Plato. Hence Whitehead's that philosophy is footnotes, essentially footnotes to Plato. So Plato was on fire with this passion for his uh whole life, and this fire was lit with the death of Socrates. And it was also my own first encounter with Plato, my first formal encounter with philosophy. Many years ago. Excuse me.
Speaker 2: And I was reminded of it a couple of weeks ago. And in turn, I was reminded of something that I had felt As a child many years before that, that also resonated in that first encounter of mine with Plato. So I suspect like many other people I I watched the coverage of the launch of NASA's mission to the moon and I didn't even expect to be drawn into it, but I found it really exciting. I stayed up late. And then I was really taken aback to discover that they were measuring the distance to the moon in miles and the size of the rocket in feet. I thought Is that s even safe? You know, is that can you do that? Is that allowed?
Speaker 2: The rocket is 322 feet tall. And this felt strangely and weirdly inappropriate or wrong. You know, if NASA had announced that For good luck. They had painted a pair of colourful eyes on the rocket, like on a Maltese fishing boat, for good luck. I wouldn't have been as surprised or or disapproving uh 322 feet tall. You know, it's one of the most ambitious machines constructed by humanity to take us to another celestial body, and they've measured it using body parts. And I had that same feeling even when I was a young child that measuring things using body parts seemed embarrassingly primitive. You know, it's like
Speaker 2: If your parents or grandparents say or do something embarrassingly, mortifyingly old-fashioned, um and If you were in the business of measuring things, especially if you wanted to be scientific about it Then the systematic, rational, predictable, orderly metric units seemed much more appropriate. than the eccentric, surprising, arbitrarily named ones that were on the opposite side of the ruler. And I couldn't really express that uh as a child, but I I I I know I f I felt it, that there was something wrong or mistaken about uh the body as an instrument of knowledge, as the basis of units of measure, that those units were too contingent on such variable things.
Speaker 2: It seemed so primitive. It felt like Uh using them to measure the world was a kind of blind and fleshy groping over it that uh you know monkey's first attempt at measuring. So how could that possibly be the basis of physical science, for example? But metric units were different. They were abstract. They weren't dependent on some arbitrary physical thing. And they were above the mundane things of the earth. And it turned out that Plato shared my feelings about this somehow, that the body is not appropriate to the pursuit of knowledge. So the Phido, this is one of the dialogues that I was given to read. It contains the conversations of Socrates with his friends in his prison cell in his last hours on Earth.
Speaker 2: In case you don't know, um in Plato's works, Socrates is the main character. They're written in the form of dialogues. And Plato's positions are spoken by Socrates , usually in conversation with others. So it's hard to know what Socrates actually thought because he didn't trouble to write anything down, he was too busy going around asking questions. Um But in in his according to Fido, in on his last night on Earth Plato is having conversations with his friends, telling them why they shouldn't worry, why he's not worried about dying, because the body's not important. The body doesn't matter. What matters is the soul or or the mind.
Speaker 2: And um he has a right old go at the body in the in the Fido. Um he's in his prison cell. He says, well In the acquisition of knowledge, is the body a hindrance or not? When is it that the soul attains to truth? When it tries to investigate anything with the help of the body, it is Obviously led astray. And when the soul uses the instrumentality of the body for any inquiry It is drawn away by the body into the realm of the variable and loses its way and becomes confused and busy and dizzy. And of course Socrates is talking about much more than units of measurement, but the fundamental intuition about what's appropriate seems to be the same, and you can see what he means.
Speaker 2: Um you know NASA's rocket was three hundred and twenty-two feet tall, which is a hundred and seven yards and one foot, because there are twelve inches in a foot and three feet in a yard, or you could say it's two thousand eight hundred and sixty-four inches, which is zero point zero. Six zero nine eight four eight five miles. And by this point I'm actually so full of confidence about the size of that rocket that you could give me any number and I'd think, yeah, that's possible. It looks like the output of a random number generator. And honestly, if I'd been one of those astronauts sitting up there, the question in my head would be, am I feeling lucky? And the serious point is that these units really don't seem to be up to the job of describing the world in a reliable, consistent, manageable,
Speaker 2: manageable way. And I promise you I'm not having a cheap laugh just by choosing some awkward numbers to make a point. Because one mile equals one thousand and one seventeen hundred and sixty yards or five thousand two hundred and eighty feet or 63,360 inches. And I've been living in the UK for well over 30 years, and this is still a mystery to me. And it turns out it's also This is where they like to use these measurements. It turns out some of this is a bit of a mystery to them as well. So if you ask them how many feet in a mile, there very few people can actually give you an answer. They can't tell you this So my own use of these things is pretty much limited to using inches to measure computer screens and miles to talk about speed limits.
Speaker 2: On the other hand, even a child can recognize rationality and rational systems. The rocket was 98 meters tall, which is say um nine thousand eight hundred centimeters or ninety eight thousand millimeters or point zero nine eight kilometers But this is a very serious thing. People get very attached to imperial measures. So in the law, like like here, UK, in the UK, the law requires sellers to sell things. Um under prices measured in kilograms. But some wanted the right to display the prices in imperial measures only. And they wanted it so badly that they were prepared to be prosecuted under trading standards legislation for it.
Speaker 2: So it seems to have calmed down now, but feelings ran really high. And for a period of ten years or so there would be regular regular stories in the news about butchers or market traders holding fast to their principles, refusing to display prices in metric units or to use scales that measured in kilograms. And they were metric martyrs. They were prosecuted for refusing to compromise their values. And what happened was that just like Socrates, they were condemned to death by being forced to drink hemlock by the authorities. Or or maybe I'm just remembering and not remembering it correctly, maybe they were just given a kind of severe telling off and told not to do it anymore. I can't remember the details, it was a while. But anyway, it was this crushing of individual
Speaker 2: uh a crushing of the individual by the state, an assault on rights and values. And of course it was all powered by the European Union. You can draw a direct line from that to the glorious revolution of uh Brexit. So which side are you on? And I don't mean the political question about the traders. I mean more about the question about the units. Because I think that it is actually, as as you see from the from the traders, it's it's a kind of question that makes people it seems to make people choose side sides. It seems to demand it. And I think it does that because it's about much more Than units. I think there's something buried in there that's important and is important.
Speaker 2: It feels important, it is important, and it makes people choose sites. Because I Felt that. For as long as I can remember thinking, it has felt to me often that the world divides itself into things that fall onto one side or the other. you know, thinking and rationality and so on on one side and bodies and materiality on the other. And it has felt to me Long before I had even the vocabulary to express any of this, that important things depended on the distinctions between the bodily and the unbodily, that things rocked around on on this axis. So when I was a teenager, computers caught by imagination.
Speaker 2: How un unbodily can you get? This is a technology that seemed removed from physicality. The important and appealing things about computers all seem to belong to that left hand side of unbodliness, of abstraction, of rationality. And Programming was the idea that you could give instructions in words to a machine, that it was possible to think one's way through a program and know what it was going to do, because the program had to follow the laws of logic. This is a world that operated according to the most implacable and rigid logical rules. This was a machine that was going to execute thought. This was a science that was above the variable bodily uh the variable disorder of bodily things.
Speaker 2: And I think Plato would have loved it And I wrestled uh with ideas and I read books and my life uh became crowded with thinkers and writers and arguers. But from those kind of childish intuitions that I couldn't even put into words and then to my studies and my preoccupations, the things that I looked for and that I struggled with. All seemed to be on that left hand side of the divide. That's where I was searching for the keys that would unlock the world, where I was sure I was going to find them. And there just wasn't much place. For the body in my intellectual map of the world for decades. But very slowly I felt the body
Speaker 2: pressing in. Maybe I'm just becoming more sympathetic to bodies more generally. Perhaps I'm as I get older I'm more aware of my own dependence on my body. I'm getting a l older along with it. Um, you know, soon my body and I we're going to be starting to approach the onset of early middle age. Um perhaps I feel that we're in this together and we need to look after each other. Um I I feel I feel a bit more grateful to it uh and more forgiving of its failings and perhaps aware that maybe I need to be forgiven too by it. I'm not sure. But I have noticed that I am comp still completely baffled by feet and and miles But some of the ideas around them
Speaker 2: have started to feel a little less alien to me. For a start, these uh famous so-called imperial units are in fact Roman units of measurement. And a mile is a nice round 1,000 paces, mile pasos. And there are lots of excellent connections because a foot is Roman too because there are five uh pedes five feet in one passus And one twelfth of a pest, pes is singular for foot in in in in Roman as um is uh one uncha one inch And twelve
Speaker 2: also seems pretty reasonable. Twelve is quite a reasonable number, it's very generously uh divisible. And so for some reason uh uncia made it into English as inch but in Italian which is much closer to Latin of course it becomes police which is some which in most languages is the word for inch the body's everywhere in in all of this Oh and just for a bonus you realize that uh uh inch and ounce both come from the same root, about twelfthness. So the body's everywhere here and it it's not a completely mad picture. And now these are Roman units, so I'm in Athens and to my Greek friends I hurriedly point out that I know perfectly well that uh
Speaker 2: Like pretty much everything else. The Romans got their units from the Greeks and they tweaked them a bit and snapped new names on them and any Greek will tell you that the Romans were mainly good for stealing Greek ideas and uh building roads and killing people But it's funny how often the Romans managed to win the global influence game. So back to these units, you've got to admit they really stuck around for some reason. They won't go away. We can't just pin that on reluctance to let go of old things. And when you look at them more closely, they start to make more sense than maybe was f at first apparent. And I think those Brexite English butchers and so on
Speaker 2: might be hanging on to some weirdly inconvenient mutations of them, but there is rational rationality in there and there are connections that make sense And they insist on referring to the body. Well, what if that were insistence also had some positive value and it were not just a defect. What if it were not just a bug, but perhaps a feature? And what I mean is, is this really the right picture of those units? That those on the left, the ones that abstract of themselves above us. That seem rational and scientific. Are they superior to the ones on the right, which seem to be mundane and contingent? Are those really bodily and just primitive?
Speaker 2: Or might be there some other value present that on one side actually we're meekly submitting to arbitrary rules. And on the other, we've got a way of in asserting ourselves upon the world, that we can express the world in terms of us. And I feel much less sure about this than I used to. And I've been thinking about it. I think it's an interesting question. And it seems to have something to say directly about another question that I've thought. About a lot, which is what makes Django 's documentation so good? So It's been consistently prioritized ever since the start of the project, of course.
Speaker 2: And we should be so grateful for the people who started Django on that path and helped keep us on it But I'm asking, what are the characteristics of the documentation itself that make it so good? Well, it's complete, it's accurate, it's consistent, it's rational, well structured, uh really well structured. Uh Plato would have loved it. Those are all Platonic values. And it's concise, and the writing itself is direct and clear, and it rarely goes off the narrow path that runs between awkward stiffness on one hand and sloppiness or casualness on the other. So it's precise without being pedantic. And it's lively and it speaks to the reader in imaginative ways. It's rich and adventurous and it's full of examples that illuminate. And again, um
Speaker 2: Maybe it's not so much like the values that Plato expresses, but it's very much like the the values that Plato demonstrates. In his writing, because he is one of the most powerful, inventive, engaging writers in the Western canon. And people say all of those things about Django's documentation. And I agree with all of those things. I think they're right. I think they make Django's documentation good. But I think that what makes what makes Django's documentation really great is something else. I think it's great. Because it fits the human body. I think it's great because it fits human needs so well by fitting the body.
Speaker 2: Okay, well, what does this mean? Uh obviously documentation isn't like clothing. Documentation doesn't seem to be a particularly bodily thing. How could documentation fit human needs like By fitting the body. And this is where I ask you to, I need you to ask you to come along with me on this a little bit. Fitting the body means being of the right size, and documentation can be an appropriate size or scale. Physically or mentally, there's only so much we can grasp At once. You can't easily grasp things that are too big or too small, either physically or or mentally. And
Speaker 2: Those things are related because the limitations of our intelligence are also the limitations of our embodied intelligence Because we are embodied beings. Our intelligence exists and works in space and time. And my hands have got this physical span that determines what they can grasp effectively. And we have also spans and limits of mental grasp and attention. And we can only hold on to so much or so many things at once and for so long without becoming tired and losing our grasp. And we tire mentally also because we tire physically.
Speaker 2: And a page of documentation can be too long. What too long means is too long to use comfortably. And comfort is not a bodily metaphor. Comfort is literally a bodily manner. So when a page is too long, handling it and navigating within it. becomes difficult. It can be taxing to work with mentally and physically. Mentally because it contains too much and physically because it lengths its length requires us to uh uh page around and jump around within it. And a list can be too long. And that's a familiar experience. You know that you can't handle a list more than about five or seven items long unless you give it some additional uh structure. It's uh um
Speaker 2: And if you break something down into smaller pieces, then you can end up with too many because you made them too small, which is as awkward to manage as something that's too big. And a page can be too short. Because it costs effort to arrive at a page. Opening one page means leaving another and losing its context, and that context took you uh effort to build. So hopping around two short pages quickly induces tiredness. And so next time you look at Django 's documentation Look at it with some of these ideas of size and scale and number in mind, because I'm actually awed by how well Django does it, how much and how often Django gets this absolutely right.
Speaker 2: And we experience documentation in time and space And our bodies have particular strengths and capacities and limitations, and they move and work in certain ways in rhythms and patterns and sequences, and bodies in their movements, they've got resting points and transition points and points of no return and they have different kinds of relationships with uh different kinds of physical objects and everybody knows what it's like to work On something and find all the things that you need at hand within reach. And think about the documentation of Django and how astoundingly well it manages to do that, to put the things that you reach for.
Speaker 2: Um, an arm 's span away. We carry mental weight When reading documentation, and think about how much mental weight the documentation asks you to carry. It has to ask you to carry some, but How much does it ask you to carry? How far does it ask you to carry it before it gives you a place to put it down? How far and how many other jumps? that you need to take between one place in the documentation another carrying weight. And I know no other documentation that accompanies me through time so effectively as Django's. I experience it as moving at my pace. as anticipating my next step. And our relationship to text is to be in it
Speaker 2: I'm always at some particular place within a text. I move through it and from one part of it to another, I orient myself in it. And being in Django 's uh documentation. Is hello? What's going on here? Um we orient ourselves in it, and being in Django's documentation is like being in a well-designed building or or a city where places stand in relation to each other. You stand at a crossroads or where two corridors meet and you can see in both directions at once and make sense of What you're in. And you know, you've all had the experience of being in buildings that are so large that they have to start repeating their internal structures, like a hospital or a hotel.
Speaker 2: And I I bet you've been in buildings that do it in ways that lose you and confuse you And perhaps you've also been in buildings that somehow do it successfully, that manage it manage to use the repetition. To educate and familiarize you. And that's a structure, sorry, that's an example of a structure with a kind of humanized rationality. And you find that in Django's documentation. And it's impossible for me to talk about what I think is good about Django's documentation without talking in the language of embodiment, talking in the language of time
Speaker 2: and space. I think that what makes Django's documentation so great is the quality of the experience. that it affords the user. And I'm not just talking about user experience, I mean experience in space and time as an embodied being. I don't know where that genius in the documentation originated or with whom, but it's remarkable how strong it is that 20 years on, so far I'm uh uh Uh 20 years on, it's still there, and people are still picking up on the patterns and repeating them. They they people who have never thought that idea explicitly still Do the documentation in that way it's so strong. I don't think anybody has pointed it out
Speaker 2: before. But successive contributors seem to also find patterns that somehow respect the embodiment of our understanding and intelligence. And I don't think Plato would have recognized the significance of that or would have maybe resisted it. And I certainly wouldn't have until more recently. So there are values in Django's documentation that we can measure, like coverage and accuracy and consistency. And there are others like its rationality and good structure that we can reason about and show evidence for, even some of the characteristics of the writing, like it's clarity and its directness and its imagination, they're ones that we can point out. And I think that Plato would have recognized too.
Speaker 2: But I think the claim that its greatness lies in how well it fits the body as a new one. And I can't show it to you. I can't measure that. But I can ask you to try on the idea, also like an item of clothing. Try on the idea as if you're trying on clothes, to feel for yourself. How this documentation fits you, fits you as someone who is an embodied intelligence, an intelligence In a spatial world that exists in time. I want to give you two more examples of What I think is happening here, of how I think that some deep understanding , or at least some powerful intuition, of the embodied nature of our intelligence has had
Speaker 2: a transformative effect on technology. When Apple launched the Macintosh, it was a new way of interacting with information space. In fact, it was a way of representing information and its organization that was explicitly spatial. And it wasn't some overlay on top of the fundamental information structures, it was an aspect of the structures and interactions themselves. And the manual, the the the the user manual had to find ways to explain all this for the first time. And I love the way ways they found to represent what they were doing. You can see the language and the concepts and the technical patterns all coming into being together. They had to invent so much at once. For example, there's scrolling, and you're asked to imagine an actual scroll
Speaker 2: Moving up and down behind a screen. There's the question of, I don't know if you could read it, where does your information go? Again, that spatial language of where where does the information go? They're trying out a metaphor. I don't know if you can see it that on the right on the far right hand side, a metaphor of a house and corridors leading to rooms And all of this, all of the manual and the way the Macintosh was first presented is addressed, it's addressed to the user. as a person with a body. A person whose intelligence is not im whose intelligence is not embodied as some kind of contingent fact about it, but whose embodiment is its defining essential nature.
Speaker 2: And as in Django, what's at stake here is the experience is that the experience that's being offered to the user is experience in space and time, that it's that of an embodied being. In in this case, the experience is Reading Just like computing can be a transformation of human experience, an extension of experience, an alteration of the way that we take in the world. It's a transformation of the world itself. And you think might think, well, okay, a book is a book. Once we got the basic idea, there we were. But until the 15th century, if you wanted to read, say, Homer, you had to go to the book. Because most most books weren't going anywhere.
Speaker 2: It might be literally chained to a table. Not always, but often. And books were huge. heavy, uncomfortable, and friendly things. People received many nasty injuries from books. And Aldus Minutius changed that. He founded the Aldean Press in Venice and he was an obsessive. He wanted to Save the world, he thought. That was his what he was going to do. He was going to save the world by printing the classics. He wanted to liberate them from their dark and gloomy prisons where they were often literally chained down to the tables. And he changed the world through technology in the same way that Apple did by
Speaker 2: Taking something that existed and doing it in a new way. And his innovation was to produce pocket-sized books. That might seem like nothing more than a change of size, but this is a turning point in the history of the book and reading. It's a transformation of what it was to read with a book in your hand that you carried around with you. It's the invention of the book as a personal item. It's the original of the modern paperback. If you're sitting on a train or in the bath or at the table with your lunch reading a book, well thank you, Albus. He designed books to fit the body. He called the book and um again he too found a Greek name for it. En it's something that you hold in your hand that you can put in your pocket. It was lit
Speaker 2: literally means a handbook. So he made reading fit the body. Because, just like Django's documentation, Aldus's books were addressed to the embodied experience, the life of a mind not just in a body, but as embodied. And of course, reading and uh books existed before Aldos, just like computers existed before the Macintosh, but these were innovations that helped turn a technology into a ubiquitous and fully fledged extension of human experience and something genuinely new uh was driven uh by aldus uh sorry it was driven for both aldus and apple by the vision of making something
Speaker 2: universally accessible. And it was powered by their attention to embodiment. I've been talking about experience, and it's one of those words that's been effectively brutalized so experience the things you can now buy like packages or we talk about customer experience or or user experience and I'm not talking about any of those things Experiences our ability to take in the world and make sense of it, to order and structure what we take in through the senses into a meaningful whole. And have the things in it placed into meaningful relations with each other. And in experience, what happens is our faculties Build a world for us. And some things in the world become extensions of ourselves.
Speaker 2: They are transformers of experience. Through them Experience itself is changed. Computers and computing and books and reading. The world we build for ourselves is transformed through them. And they're not the only examples of technologies and activities that can do that, but they're too. Interesting ones, I think. And it's just about impossible to talk about things of the mind without using language of the body. If all of the things I've said about the mind have in this conversation so far, nearly all of them have been using bodily language And I thought of those examples in just a few minutes, and they're only in English, and you can find them all and other ones in other languages. And you say, well, yes, those are bodily metaphors. But no, then they're not metaphors.
Speaker 2: They represent the nature of mental space itself. So we have you know I talked about grasping, grasping an idea. Well that's seizing and taking, so comprehend or apprehend or perceive. They all come from the idea of seizing or taking or to ponder or weigh something up to to to fathom. That that's all based on measuring. We jump to conclusions and we take intuitive leaps and w we stumble and trip in our thoughts. Bodily movement, bodily sensation. We have ideas it's related to seeing or I feel you know I feel that we we talk about feeling when we're talking about rationalizing sapience to do with tasting that's where it comes from Intuition to looking again look looking. Bodily events, conceiving and and concepts. Well that that's pretty a pretty bodily event.
Speaker 2: Knowledge also has connections to sexuality. Words like understand, which means something like um uh being amid being amidst, being in between. Or position. My position on this subject is those are about spatiality. It's almost impossible to talk about. What happens in the mind without talking in the language of space and time, without talking in the body's language? So I don't think they are metaphors. They represent the nature of mental space itself.
Speaker 2: In fact, even that phrase mental space, I don't think that's a metaphor. I'm not saying there might be five centimeters between one thought and another in my head. No, that's not what I mean. I'm insisting that there is I'm not saying there's physical space in there between thoughts. It's rather I think that mental and physical space belong to the same fundamental structures of our ability to experience anything at all. And they're completely bound up in each other. That space is an aspect of us as certainly as we are in space. I don't know if anyone's seen this man for a while. It's been a long time. In case you don't recognize him, it's Django, another. former Django Core team member, a longtime contributor, and I miss him.
Speaker 2: I really miss him at especially at the sprints. Because I'd love going up to find him and ask him, Russell, I've got an idea or I've got a question. And it's about such and such. And I'd ask him something about something quite deep in Django. Deep, there's another spatial word for you. I'd ask him about something in Django. And then He would just close his eyes together for a moment and his gaze would turn inward. And in his mind And I think this is literal and not metaphorical. In his mind, he was seeing Django as a code base, as an intellectual structure. And he was moving through mental space. He would be going deeper and deeper as as I asked
Speaker 2: questions. He was looking at things. He was going into them. He was moving things around to see behind them in his mind. Django was in his mind and he was in Django in those moments. And he'd be talking through him, uh he'd be talking himself through this at the same time, reporting back on it. And then finally he'd pop back into the world. You know, it's a kind of blink. And I think that Russell's cognitive activity, his experience in those moments, would have been essentially the same as if he'd been working his way through some complex physical space. And you know how brain scientists love putting people inside MRI scanners and then they say that um
Speaker 2: So the newspapers and headlines about the you know uh oh yeah when somebody's solving a Rubik's cube, it's activating exactly the same parts of the brain as when they're conjugating French verbs or something like that, you know. So I bet if we put Russell into an MRI scanner, we'd discover that the parts of his brain that were activated when he's working his way through a problem at a Django sprint were exactly the same one. ones are activated when he's working his navigating his way through a city. It would be interesting if we could get Russell and an MRI scanner at the next sprints to to look at this. And I think that my idea of programming as an activity that belongs specially to this world of language and logic wasn't quite right. Well of course yes logic and rationality and conceptualization are key in that.
Speaker 2: And as people who are accomplished now, we think about our prowess and competency as software programmers in those terms. What concepts I grasp, the depth and sophistication of my intellectual approach, the ideas, but I think it's really far from the whole story. Watch a learner writing uh writing software, doing something with software, computing, and their hesitations and their errors and their struggles and their triumphs will largely be about things like Which file or directory to be in? Where to expect the output? When to expect it, where to enter a command, when to do something, in what order to do things. And these are challenges of space and time.
Speaker 2: They're not just conceptual challenges. And the challenge is to become familiar with the tool itself, familiar with the tool in the hand. And they're challenges that we forget. that we faced, just like we forget the challenge of having learned to walk or to talk, because they belong to our embodiment. In fact, language use is is a good comparison because we can reason about And conceptualize the activity. But it depends on our having first acquired it as a bodily skill. And look at the body of the expert at work and their movements in time and space, and they're fluid and accurate and fast
Speaker 2: and precise, and they're unhurried. And they're actions that anticipate outputs that queue up complex sequences into economical flows. And I'm not talking about sculptors or brain surgeons. I'm talking about software engineers, programmers. Even in programming, a substantial part of the skill belongs to the body. The body is always in knowledge. So what does it matter? Why should you care? So you know, Daniela read Plato 30 years ago, and now we've got to listen to his opinions. You know, he could have stayed at home bothering Plato instead of coming all the way to Athens to do it. And, you know, I have could have some sympathy with that. But I think it's an interesting way to have an answer for Plato
Speaker 2: about the body and about the nature of understanding. And I think it helps. Me feel a bit differently about the body and my relationship with my own. And I think it might be a new and interesting way to reason about things like quality and documentation. And about the human experience of computing. And I think it's a lens on software and our work, on the things we do and the things we take for granted. Maybe it can help us Ask some pointed questions. So you're familiar with infinite scrolling and its uglier cousin doom scrolling. Well what's in that pattern that seems to be so troublesome? Well it's it has some troublesome effects. But Is there a possibility they're connected to the fact that infinite scrolling is a pattern that itself
Speaker 2: ruptures expectations of experience? It's a violation of our contract of a noble world. I'd be happy to see some hard-eyed judge or legislator asking tech bros questions about this in uh uh courts, for example. Does it matter that so much of our computing now abstracts away from the material details that underlie the concerns, but it it erases their limits. So all my understanding of programming and computing has come from running up against limits. Running out of memory of disk space of storage of CPU power. I've got a query set and it's too expensive. I'm running into limits made out of physics and logic. I can construct a meaningful world out of that.
Speaker 2: I need those edges to run into, even if it hurts sometimes, because and where will I find those edges? Where will I experience those edges in a world made out of cloudless, infinitely expandable, uh uh sorry, edgeless, infinitely expandable cloud resources. And a computer world can be a world of experience too, because it behaves like the world governed by cause and effect, laws of physics and logic. What happens to our experiences in computing When they become increasingly indeterministic as we spend more time interacting with LNMs. And I'm not saying that these are bad things, but I see a similar uncanny pattern, a similar uncanny thing in each of them.
Speaker 2: And I'm asking a question, what does it matter? that these are cognitive relationships that seem to disregard the embodied nature of our cognition. If I'm right about these things, that the nature of our understanding and intelligence is to be embodied and that that's significant, then maybe that gives us some suggestions about what good should look like in computing. What good should look like when we're making the software, when we're making the things that are going to be part of people's, other people's experience of the world. Because If a crucial aspect of the nature of our intelligence is to be embodied
Speaker 2: If the body is always in knowledge, then I think probably computing ought to be fitted to and fit for the embodied mind. Thank you.
Speaker 3: Thank you, Daniela. I think we have time for one question and then we'll all take five minutes to reflect on such an incredible talk. Carlton, of course. I mean he did study philosophy, so there we go.
Speaker 4: Wow, thank you. Um Do you think at all that the um that the the the themes you're talking about have anything to to to do any relation to the r romantic reaction to the kind of cold enlightenment Is it the similar is it a similar pushback?
Speaker 2: The romantic reaction to a call enlightenment, like starting to devalue the body again after I think the world our world, our time now, so many things are going on and so many things are happening so fast that Maybe in 200 years people will look and say, oh, just like there was the romantic age, there was the romantic there was the age of such and such. But we're in it and all I see are these things in this incredible flux. And I I couldn't say that there is such a uh a pattern in the world. I mean personally my own reaction about the the the feeling more sympathy to the body, maybe there's something in in
Speaker 2: in in there. Um I don't know. I I haven't I haven't really felt people talking about this way very much about computing. Is that something that you think you've uh seen?
Speaker 4: As you were talking, it it struck me that um the romanticism seems to be that same. pushback for the human in the yeah.
Speaker 2: Pushback for on behalf of the human. Yeah.
Speaker 4: Anyway, thank you.
Speaker 2: But it's not against the it's not against the rationality, it's not against i even the calculation. things like greed or exploitation for uh exploit let's for example we were talking about this yesterday exploitation of volunteer effort in open source communities in open source projects by uh companies that have vast amounts of money and rely on the work of volunteer maintainers. So there are imbalances of um power and commitment, you know, that some people seem to be doing all the work and some people seem to be Yeah, uh getting all the the benefits. So there's definitely a pushback on there on behalf of the human.
Speaker 2: Yeah. Thank you.
Speaker 3: Thank you very much, Tandea. Round of applause, please. Such an incredible talk. We'll just take a five minute break and then we'll be into the next talk. Thank you.
April 15 - 17, 2026
Athens, Greece
Note: We understand that names change, people change, and bodies change. We respect each individual's journey and privacy. If you have any concerns about a video or need us to remove content, please don't hesitate to contact us. We will handle your request with care and promptly address any issues.
Published October 26, 2026
Published October 26, 2026
Published October 26, 2026
Published October 26, 2026
Published October 26, 2026
Published October 26, 2026